If the Yankees secure Juan Soto, likely a $600 million acquisition, they’ll strengthen their roster with one of MLB’s most potent hitters. But if Soto decides on another path, the Yankees will need solid alternatives to fill the gap he’d leave in the outfield and the lineup. Here are four promising options:
1. Cody Bellinger – Bellinger has revived his career with the Cubs and would bring elite defense and versatility to the Yankees’ outfield. His recent offensive rebound has him looking closer to his MVP form, adding both power and a left-handed bat to balance the lineup.
2. Bryan Reynolds – Reynolds has been a consistent hitter for the Pirates, and his switch-hitting ability and strong OBP would boost the Yankees’ offense. His more affordable contract could also allow New York to pursue additional pitching or other roster needs.
3. Teoscar Hernández – Known for his power, Hernández could provide the Yankees with an immediate power boost. Though his defense isn’t elite, his offensive production could fill the void left by Soto, especially in Yankee Stadium’s hitter-friendly environment.
4. Eloy Jiménez – With an impressive power profile, Jiménez has shown glimpses of stardom despite injuries. If he can stay healthy, his power potential makes him a strong Soto alternative. Jiménez could also come at a more reasonable cost, enabling the Yankees to retain financial flexibility.
Each of these players would help keep the Yankees competitive if they miss out on Soto. However, Soto’s unique mix of power, patience, and age make him the ideal target—one the Yankees might go all in for.