As the New York Yankees prepare for the 2025 season, tough roster decisions are on the horizon. Following a disappointing 2024 campaign, the Yankees are looking for ways to bolster their lineup and ensure a stronger, more consistent performance. Among the players who may be on the chopping block are those who struggled to meet expectations or have not shown the growth needed to remain in the team’s long-term plans. Here are three players who could be wearing different uniforms next year.
1. Isiah Kiner-Falefa
After two seasons with the Yankees, Kiner-Falefa has struggled to establish himself as a core piece of the team’s infield. Known for his defensive versatility, he’s been a useful utility player but has consistently underperformed at the plate. With young prospects and a need to bring in more offensive firepower, the Yankees may decide it’s time to move on from Kiner-Falefa to make room for more productive hitters.
2. Josh Donaldson
Donaldson, a former MVP, was brought in to add veteran leadership and power to the Yankees’ lineup. However, injuries and declining performance have hindered his contributions, and he’s been a costly addition. With his large contract and limited upside heading into another season, the Yankees may look to trade or release Donaldson, clearing up salary space for potential new acquisitions.
3. Luis Severino
Once a promising ace for the Yankees, Severino’s recent seasons have been plagued by injuries and inconsistency. Though he has had flashes of brilliance, his inability to stay healthy has been a significant concern. Severino’s contract is up, and with question marks surrounding his durability, the Yankees may decide not to re-sign him, opting instead to invest in a more reliable starting pitcher.
As the offseason unfolds, these three players’ futures will be closely watched. While they have each brought something unique to the Yankees, the team’s need for stability and fresh talent may signal their departure as they gear up for a more competitive 2025 season.
